2018 Fantasy Baseball Week 9 Pitching Planner: Que Padre!

by Tyler Thompson
2018 Fantasy Baseball Week 9 Pitching Planner

Alright, doing the weekly recap of my favorite starts was a hit last week. Why mess with a good thing? Here are a few of the starts that stood out to me in the first half of Week 8.


  • "Why is it that Miles Mikolas is still underrated?" That's what I wrote in the Week 8 Pitching Planner. Note, that was BEFORE his complete game shutout of the Royals at home. Mikolas is absolutely on fire right now and definitely not going anywhere.
  • Death, taxes and Nick Pivetta is a beast. That's a sentence I didn't really expect to write out in the preseason. Anyone got that time machine worked out yet?
  • I want so badly to believe in you, Jose Berrios! After a stellar performance against the Tigers, he's reeling me back in with his line. While inconsistency has been an issue in his career, he's still a nice season-long asset for fantasy owners.


  • This year's Dinelson Lamet (R.I.P) is going to be Caleb Smith of the Marlins. With a K-rate above 30% and a BB-rate that would even make Lamet blush, Smith is going to be tough to gauge for opposing batters. Checking out the game log, the walks come in bunches. However, all but three of his ten starts have been great and I'm buying into his 2018 campaign. Oh, right, the part about his most recent start - 6 2/3 innings with eight punchouts and just two walks. Baller status.

Embed from Getty Images


  • Another week and we get another amazing start from Kenta Maeda. 12 strikeouts in just 6 2/3 shutout innings is a noteworthy day for any pitcher. Maeda is proving to be a fantastic value on his 2018 ADP.
  • Nope, not even going to go into detail on Dylan Covey. I've got bigger fish to fry! Is anyone else hungry? Or borderline hangry?
  • Wednesday was 'Winners Day' in Week 8 with 2018 aces showing their worth. Jake Arrieta, Jacob deGrom, and Justin Verlander all showed out.


  • Oooooh that Snell! Can't you smell Blake Snell? In a rotation of misfits, Snell has provided the Rays with some life as their ACE. Against a potent Boston lineup, he tossed six shutout innings with eight strikeouts while allowing just five baserunners. He's very close to cracking my Auto-Stream tier, not that anyone cares.
  • What the literal hell happened for Dylan Bundy in that last start? Do you think the MLB higher-ups set him up for a drug test after his complete-game, 14-K masterpiece? I mean holy bejeezus that was unexpected. I will stick to my guns and say sell high because this dude is basically Kevin Gausman 2.0 - unreliable and frustrating as hell.

Now, let's dive into Week 9 and separate the men from the boys and the starters from the sitters.

2018 Fantasy Baseball Week 9 Pitching Planner

Get customized Fantasy Baseball advice for your team using MyPlaybook from FantasyPros.


The Auto-Start tier strictly includes pitchers that should be started every week regardless of league size and matchup.

Max ScherzerNationals@BAL
Chris SaleRed Sox@HOU
Corey KluberIndiansCWS
Noah SyndergaardMetsCHC
Luis SeverinoYankeesHOU
Jacob deGromMets@ATLCHC
Justin VerlanderAstros@NYYBOS
Gerrit ColeAstrosBOS


  • There were no promotions this week.


  • There were no relegations this week. Moving on!


This tier consists of pitchers who don't quite reach the trust level of the Auto-Starts. However, due to matchup or recent performance, they are capable of having elite level production in a given week.

James PaxtonMarinersTEX
Shohei OhtaniAngels@DETTEX
Zack GreinkeDiamondbacksMIA
Stephen StrasburgNationals@ATL
Walker BuehlerDodgers@COL
Carlos CarrascoIndians@MIN
Aaron NolaPhillies@LAD
Lance McCullers Jr.AstrosBOS
Charlie MortonAstros@NYYBOS


  • Shohei Ohtani had his start against the Yankees pushed back to this week. The Angels are acting weird and I don't like it sometimes, but there is some good from this. He now gets a definite start against an inferior foe if not two in Week 9. Alright, Angels, I'm in! Update: He will just get one start against the Tigers in Week 9.
  • I feel like I talk about Walker Buehler every week. Why not though? His numbers are borderline elite although he hasn't been exposed to the 'third time through order' curse very often. Just as in his last start of seven innings, I'm expecting the Dodgers to stretch him out more and more once he's ready.

Embed from Getty Images

  • Welcome to the Auto-Stream group, Lance McCullers Jr.! By the way, if you aren't following this dude on Twitter, you aren't a real pitching junkie. Oh, and, by the way, I tried to say I'd be there. WAITING FOR!!! Wait, what are we waiting for? What are we even talking about? It's 3:40 AM, my apologies.
  • In a pitching landscape where no one is consistent, I wish I would have snagged Zack Greinke on one of my teams. Looking more closely at his statistics, check out his home/road splits. The humidor at Chase Field has definitely made an impact and Greinke is enjoying the benefits. Homers have been an issue on the road, but it would stand to reason that Greinke the veteran can trim those issues down as the season wears on.

Dream Stream

The Dream Stream group more closely reflects the pitchers that you are contemplating starting or sitting. These are all worthy starters in a typical 12-team mixed league.

Yu DarvishCubs@NYM
Chris ArcherRays@OAK@SEA
Garrett RichardsAngelsTEX
Kenta MaedaDodgersPHI@COL
Jose QuintanaCubs@NYM
Tyler SkaggsAngels@DETTEX
Blake SnellRays@OAK
Trevor BauerIndians@MIN
David PriceRed SoxTOR@HOU
Alex WoodDodgersPHI
Masahiro TanakaYankees@BAL
Tyson RossPadresMIACIN
Patrick CorbinDiamondbacksCIN
Jon LesterCubs@PIT@NYM
Dallas KeuchelAstros@NYY
Jameson TaillonPirates@STL
J.A. HappBlue Jays@DET
Jon GrayRockiesSF
Jake ArrietaPhillies@LAD@SF
Eduardo RodriguezRed SoxTOR
Clayton RichardPadresMIA
Kyle HendricksCubs@PIT
Eric LauerPadresMIACIN
Vince VelasquezPhillies@LAD@SF
Gio GonzalezNationals@BAL@ATL
Nick PivettaPhillies@SF
Rick PorcelloRed SoxTOR@HOU
Zack GodleyDiamondbacksCIN
Luiz GoharaBravesNYMWSH
Andrew HeaneyAngels@DET
Alex ReyesCardinals@MILPIT
Nathan EovaldiRays@OAK@SEA
Jordan LylesPadresMIA
Luis CastilloReds@ARZ
Mike MinorRangers@SEA
Luke WeaverCardinals@MILPIT
Michael WachaCardinals@MIL
Jose BerriosTwinsCLE
Sonny GrayYankees@BAL
Ross StriplingDodgersPHI
Mike ClevingerIndiansCWS@MIN
Caleb SmithMarlins@SD@ARZ
Steven MatzMets@ATL
Danny DuffyRoyalsMIN
Sean NewcombBravesWSH
Tanner RoarkNationals@ATL
Marco GonzalesMarinersTEXTB
Miles MikolasCardinalsPIT
Jack FlahertyCardinalsPIT
Trevor CahillAthletics@KC
Fernando RomeroTwinsTEXTB
Felix HernandezMariners@KC
Tyler MahleReds@SD
Sean ManaeaAthleticsTB


  • Am I giddy about acquiring Clayton Richard or Eric Lauer to stream in Week 9? Not really. However, with the Marlins and Reds on the seven-game schedule this week, you gotta roll the dice. If it's ratios you are after, give the dependable Richard a try. On the other hand, Lauer is an upside play with the potential for a handful of strikeouts.
  • Okay, I'm really freaking tired of talking about the Cardinals' rotation. Hopefully, we get some clarity on what they want to do once Alex Reyes and Carlos Martinez return. (For the record, I'm starting Reyes with no hesitation this week.) Who will be the odd man out between Luke Weaver and Jack Flaherty? If I'm putting my Mike Matheny hat on, Flaherty goes back to Triple-A. However, in my eyes, it should be Weaver getting the short-term ax. We shall see!

Embed from Getty Images

  • Oh man, my boy Luiz Gohara is back in the starting rotation. Now, he has been on a pitch limit in the early going, but I can see him going five or six strong innings. The K-upside is too good to pass up here, especially against the Mets. I would pass on the Nationals start (if he even gets that chance). Be ahead of the curve and snag him now for that NYM start.
  • While Nate Eovaldi finds his way in the streaming tier, be extra careful here. I am going off numbers from two years ago and not feeling great about it. The Rays have also been extremely particular about their pitching this year, so it is more than likely that Eovaldi only goes three or four innings before getting yanked. On second thought, don't start Eovaldi. My goof, guys. Insert shoulder shrug emoji.

Buyer Beware

These pitchers are better left on your bench for the week if not the waiver wire. Guys closer to the top could be on the brink of being promoted in the right matchup or with a continued hot streak. If a player is not listed in any tiers, that should be the cue to drop the said player.

Jeff SamardzijaGiants@COL
Drew PomeranzRed Sox@HOU
Wade LeBlancMarinersTEX
Joe MusgrovePiratesCHC
Cole HamelsRangers@LAA
Mike FoltynewiczBravesWSH
Andrew SuarezGiants@COLPHI
Michael FulmerTigersLAATOR
Tyler AndersonRockiesLAD
Blaine HardyTigersTOR
German MarquezRockiesLAD
Robbie ErlinPadresCIN
Brandon McCarthyBravesNYMWSH
Wei-Yen ChenMarlins@SD
Zack DaviesBrewersSTL
Zack WheelerMets@ATLCHC
Jakob JunisRoyalsMINOAK
Tyler ChatwoodCubs@PIT@NYM
Kyle GibsonTwins@KCCLE
Julio TeheranBravesNYM
Nick TropeanoAngels@DET
Brent SuterBrewersSTL@CWS
Ivan NovaPiratesCHC@STL
Dan StrailyMarlins@SD@ARZ
Aaron SanchezBlue Jays@BOS@DET
Marco EstradaBlue Jays@BOS
Junior GuerraBrewersSTL
Domingo GermanYankeesHOU@BAL
Jose UrenaMarlins@SD
Jeremy HellicksonNationalsBAL@ATL
Zack EflinPhillies@LAD
Jaime GarciaBlue Jays@DET
Chase AndersonBrewers@CWS
Trevor WilliamsPirates@STL
Lance LynnTwins@KCCLE
Jake OdorizziTwinsCLE
Eric SkoglundRoyalsMIN
Reynaldo LopezWhite Sox@CLE
Chris StrattonGiantsPHI
Daniel MengdenAthleticsTB
Jhoulys ChacinBrewers@CWS
Matt HarveyReds@SD
Sal RomanoReds@ARZ
Derek HollandGiants@COL
Mike LeakeMarinersTB
Chad KuhlPiratesCHC@STL
Ian KennedyRoyalsOAK
CC SabathiaYankeesHOU@BAL
Doug FisterRangers@SEA@LAA
Kyle FreelandRockiesSF
Daniel GossettAthleticsTB@KC
Dylan BundyOriolesWSHNYY
Matt BoydTigersLAATOR
Jason HammelRoyalsOAK
Ty BlachGiantsPHI
Bartolo ColonRangers@SEA


  • Imagine hearing the Jaws music and being scared shitless only to turn around and see a goldfish. That's what Jeff Samardzija has been like this year. People are scared to drop him because of the namesake, but he's just a little goldfish! Flush him down the toilet and go find you a better streaming option this week.
  • A name that may have slipped under the radar in your league is Joe Musgrove. Returning from his rehab starts this week, he will get a more-than-fair chance to stick in the rotation long-term. The Pirates had a definite plan in mind for him when acquiring him from Houston and they must see something they like in the guy. This change of scenery just might be what he needed to revamp his career.

Embed from Getty Images

  • Okay, who are you and what have you done with Zach Eflin? I have no idea what to make of this. On one hand, you have a career 5.34 ERA and 5.45 FIP with a subpar minor league history. On the other hand, the new Phillies coaching staff has already revamped Nick Pivetta and Jake Arrieta this year. He's definitely worth a watch-list, but I'm leaning towards fluke.
  • Speaking of flukes, say hello to my friend Junior Guerra! It's fun to ride the hot hand, but don't fool yourselves here. His HR/9 has decreased miraculously from 2.30 in 2017 to 0.64 this year. That's despite almost identical batted ball data from the two seasons. It's about to get ugly for Mr. Jr. unfortunately.
  • If you are dying for extra streamers, I'm good with rolling both Michael Fulmer and Brandon McCarthy in their good starts. If you can't pick out which start is good for them, then I would suggest not starting them. Just saying!

Arms Amending

This is usually where I put the players that are on the disabled list or making rehab appearances. Not only is it important to know where they are in their recovery, but knowing who will be replacing them is key as well.

Clayton KershawDodgersBiceps tendinitisSoon!
Joey LucchesiPadresStrained right hipSoon!
Anthony DeSclafaniRedsStrained obliqueSoon!
Carlos MartinezCardinalsRight lat strainEarly June
Mike SorokaBravesShoulder tightnessEarly June
Ervin SantanaTwinsFinger surgeryEarly June
Robbie RayDiamondbacksOblique strainMid June
Madison BumgarnerGiantsFractured fingerMid June
Marcus StromanBlue JaysShoulder fatigueMid June
Carlos RodonWhite SoxShoulder surgeryMid June
Rich HillDodgersBlisterLate June
Yonny ChirinosRaysForearm strainLate June
Johnny CuetoGiantsElbow inflammationEarly July
Jordan MontgomeryYankeesElbow strainEarly July
Hyun-Jin RyuDodgersGroin strainAll-Star Break
Jimmy NelsonBrewersShoulder surgeryAll-Star Break
Matt ShoemakerAngelsStrained forearmAll-Star Break
Jake FariaRaysLeft oblique strainAll-Star Break
Shelby MillerDiamondbacksTommy John surgeryAll-Star Break


  • Word on the street is that Clayton Kershaw could forgo rehab appearances and return to the rotation next weekend. Well, when you're Clayton freakin' Kershaw, why not?
  • The Reds have to be amped to finally (maybe) see Anthony DeSclafani in their starting staff after a season and a half of waiting. This dude can never stay healthy, so don't ever count on that. However, when he has been out there, he's been a decent fantasy option and worth a speculative grab in medium-sized leagues.

Embed from Getty Images

  • As if his injury history couldn't get more unlucky, Carlos Rodon had a weird occurrence in his rehab appearance recently. While his shoulder feels just fine, he did get popped in the head by a comebacker. There was a big gash on his head, so yeah it was a big deal. I'm guessing that Chicago wants to let him rest up after that and re-ramp up his activity before returning to a rotation that desperately needs him.
  • Strangely enough, Ervin Santana was forced to prove the organization that he can get his velocity back up. His rehab starts haven't been great and the velocity from last year's great campaign is gone. Hopefully, Santana can fix this up with a few more minor league innings under his belt.
  • Tough blow for Jake Faria, who suffers the dreaded oblique strain. The Rays have already stated that it will be close to two months for him on the rehab trail, which is brutal for fantasy owners. Therefore, it's time to drop him in redraft leagues.

Check out the rest of our great 2018 Fantasy Baseball content.

You may also like


Saturday, May 26, 2018 - Fantasy Baseball Links - FantasyRundown.com May 26, 2018 - 9:50 am

[…] 9: With a number of starters getting two turns this week, FantasySixPack.net helps you get your rotations ready with their pitching […]

Monday, May 28, 2018 - Fantasy Baseball Links - FantasyRundown.com May 28, 2018 - 9:30 am

[…] 9: With a number of starters getting two turns this week, FantasySixPack.net helps you get your rotations ready with their pitching […]


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

F6P Badges Banner

Follow us on social media


A Six Pack of Fantasy Sports

Copyright © 2024 Fantasy Six Pack.