2022 Fantasy Baseball: Overvalued Pitchers

by Mike Bonni
2018 Fantasy Baseball Starting Pitchers Preview

Welcome everyone to the 2022 Fantasy Baseball: Overvalued Pitchers article. In this article, I will be going over the pitchers being valued too high in Fantasy Baseball drafts.

First off, I'm not saying don't draft these guys, but where they are being ranked right now, it's not worth the pick. If they fall a few picks, or even a round or two, jump on the opportunity.

I probably don't need to say this, but as always, be careful drafting pitchers early. They are the most susceptible to injuries (Jacob deGrom) and can really hurt your season if they go down.

2022 Fantasy Baseball: Overvalued Pitchers

Looking for a Fantasy advantage? Get prepared for the upcoming season by using the free FantasyPros Draft Wizard.

Don't Be Reaching For The Stars

Reaching for these guys can really cost you in your drafts.

Aaron Nola, Philadelphia Phillies (P12)

What happened to Aaron Nola in 2021? He was supposed to be a star pitcher in fantasy, but he absolutely wet the bed on that one.

In 2021, Aaron Nola went 9-9 with a 4.63 ERA (highest since 2016). His H/9 (8.2; highest since 2017), and HR/9 (1.3) were career-worsts.

His HR% (3.5%) is his career-worst. However, that's not the worst of it. In Aaron Nola's career, his GB% is sitting at 48.5%. Now in 2021, it dropped all the way down to 40.8%. This could be the reason why his H/9 was so high, along with his ERA.

Luis Castillo, Cincinnatti Red (P23)

Do not get burned again by Luis Castillo. Last year, he was ranked in the top-15, then proceeded to be the worst pick for many fantasy players. Most people probably sent him to the waiver wire, to be honest.

Now it's 2021 and we are in the same boat. He is now being ranked as P23, which is incredibly too high.

Last year, Luis Castillo was 8-16 with a 3.98 ERA (led the league). He had career-worst numbers in WHIP (1.364), H/9 (8.7), and BB/9 (3.6). What's really alarming is that his K% dropped almost 7% points from 2020 and around 4% lower than his career. That was his shtick too, so if he is struggling with that then he is in trouble.

Leave him off your draft boards and let someone else deal with him.

Be Wary of One-Hit Wonders

Are they the real deal? Or no?

Embed from Getty Images

Robbie Ray, Seattle Mariners (P14)

Last year, Robbie Ray was the AL Cy Young award-winner last year. He was 13-7 and led the league in WAR (6.7), ERA (2.84), and K's (248).

You are probably thinking, why is he on here? Well, other than in 2021, Robbie Ray has been mediocre at best.

In 2019, Robbie Ray had an ERA of 4.48 and in 2020, he had a 6.62 ERA. His career BB/9 (3.9) is troublesome and it looks like most of his numbers in 2021 were outliers.

Logan Webb, San Francisco Giants (P26)

Logan Webb was the darling of everyone's eye in the MLB Playoffs. He put his name on the map in 2021, but can he sustain that success? In his previous two seasons, he was nowhere near this electric. Time will tell to see if this was a one-hit-wonder or not.

Last year, Logan Webb went 11-3 with a 3.03 ERA and a very impressive BB/9 (0.5), HR/9 (0.5), and a FIP of 2.72. That's insane. He also had a career-best in WHIP (1.106) and K/9 (9.6).

In 2021, Logan Webb went over 100 innings for the first time in his career. This is something to be alarmed about, along with the fact that his previous career-low ERA was 5.22. His numbers in 2021 compared to his career numbers is something to look out for.

I'm not saying don't draft Logan Webb, but be cautious when taking him.

The Free Agents

When will they sign? As of right now, they aren't on a team and should not be drafted this high.

Embed from Getty Images

Carlos Rodon, Free Agent (P. 32)

Carlos Rodon, just like Clayton Kershaw below, deserves to be on a team. It's just a matter of when and where he will sign.

Last year, Carlos Rodon was lights out. He was 13-5 with a 2.37 ERA and a very impressive 12.6 K/9. Unfortunately, he was dealing with injuries at the end of the year, so he couldn't improve upon those stats.

All of this sounds good if he was on a team. Coming in at pitcher 32, there is no reason to be drafting him there just yet. Wait till he signs with a team, then you can take him there.

Until then, let him slip a few rounds.

Clayton Kershaw, Free Agent (P. 49)

It's a little jarring to see Clayton Kershaw, not on the dodgers. One of the greatest pitchers of this generation is currently a free agent (age 33) and that doesn't sit right with me.

Let's hope he finds a team soon. Until then, leave him off your draft boards. He is not worth this high of a pick without being on a team.

Last year, Clayton Kershaw went 10-8 with a 3.55 ERA.


That should do it for the 2022 Fantasy Baseball: Overvalued Pitchers article.

Be sure to bookmark the 2022 Fantasy Baseball Draft Kit, where all articles from our team will be featured for the 2022 Fantasy Baseball season.

You may also like


Shawn February 18, 2022 - 9:36 am

I don’t understand why fantasy managers wouldn’t take pitchers above hitters. The notion that one hitter plays all week when a pitcher only plays once bit me last year when everyone’s pitchers were putting up 30 points per pitcher per day and my best hitters were lucky to average 5 points per day. It took 6 position players to have excellent games every day for a week to do what one pitcher did in a single game. Do yourself a favor and draft pitching first for head to head leagues.

Andrew Coatess March 16, 2022 - 10:13 am

Baseball fantasy is as serious as playing or betting for an actual baseball game. There is so much to unpack in the game. Thanks for sharing:)

Kane Holland March 26, 2022 - 11:59 am

I think baseball is a special sport at some point. I once read a series about this baseball sport. I was really drawn to pitchers.I have read the information from here, thanks for sharing the useful information.


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Follow us on social media

A Six Pack of Fantasy Sports

Copyright © 2022 Fantasy Six Pack.